I'm halfway through The Welcome Wagon's debut album Welcome to the Welcome Wagon. I heard one of their tracks on an asthmatic kitty sampler that piqued my interest and then my interest only increased as I read Paste and other random blurbs. Read this blurb about Sufjan recording and producing their album. More importantly, read the Paste article: Keepers of the Faith Thrive in the Hipster's Den.
UPDATE: Read Brent Thomas's freshly baked album review.
Actually, buy the album first, and read the articles as you enjoy!
If you need further convincing, check this out: